Resort Communities in the Middle Keys Offering Home Ownershi

Lisi Caldwell • March 28, 2022

Resort Communities in the Middle Keys Offering Home Ownership


The Middle Keys are home to some of the most desirable resort style communities in the Florida Keys, offering a blend of luxury, waterfront access, and investment potential. Whether you're looking for a vacation retreat, investment property, or full-time residence, these communities provide exceptional opportunities for homeownership.


1. Tranquility Bay Beach House Resort


A waterfront paradise in Marathon, Tranquility Bay features two- and three-bedroom beach houses with stunning Gulf views. Residents and guests enjoy private beaches, pools, and resort amenities, making it an ideal daily rental investment property. The resort’s onsite management ensures professional oversight, providing a seamless experience for both guests and owners


2. Indigo Reef Marina Homes


This gated waterfront community offers spacious townhomes with direct water access and open water views. Perfect for boating enthusiasts, Indigo Reef provides private docks, lush landscaping, and a peaceful atmosphere while maintaining proximity to Marathon’s conveniences. Indigo Reef is perfect for a permanent residence, second home, or weekly rental (7-day min), making it a great investment opportunity.


3. Village at Hawks Cay, Marina Condominiums and The Sanctuary 


Located on Duck Key, this resort style community features Key West-style townhomes, waterfront condominiums and pool front single-family homes.Owners have multiple options to generate rental income, including self-managing their rentals, working with an off site property manager or onsite through the Hawks Cay Resort management program. Homeowners can enjoy the world-class amenities of Hawks Cay Resort—including pools, a spa, dining, and a full-service marina—by participating in the resort’s rental management program. These daily rental properties, offer flexibility for short-term stays while maximizing investment potential.


4. Coral Lagoon and The Boat House


A boutique waterfront community, Coral Lagoon offers spacious townhomes & single-family homes with deep-water dockage and easy access to the Atlantic Ocean. The community is known for its tranquil setting, upscale finishes, and strong rental potential. The onsite full-service marina is a boater's dream. Coral Lagoon offers daily rentals, making it a great investment opportunity while also serving as a second home or vacation retreat.

As a seasoned real estate agent with extensive experience in resort-style properties, I specialize in helping buyers navigate the unique opportunities these communities offer. If you're considering an investment property or vacation home in the Middle Keys, I’d love to assist you in finding the perfect property. Let’s connect and explore your options!


florida keys landing strips
By Lisi Caldwell January 30, 2024
For aviation enthusiasts, owning a home near a landing strip or within a flight-friendly neighborhood is the ultimate convenience. The Florida Keys offer a unique blend of coastal beauty and aviation accessibility, making them an ideal location for pilots who want the freedom to land and take off with ease.
Moving to the Florida Keys? Things You Should Know
By Lisi Caldwell January 30, 2024
If you’ve ever dreamed of swapping concrete jungles for salty breezes, the Florida Keys might be your perfect escape. I’ve helped many clients make the transition to island life, and if you’re considering the move, there are a few important realities to bear in mind.